Page 1 of 2
advice please ?
Posted: Wed Oct 03, 2012 9:29 pm
by ali
Re: advice please ?
Posted: Wed Oct 03, 2012 9:40 pm
by Edweird
What sort of off roading do you think you'll be doing, wet or dry? The Vitara engines will be more responsive, revvier and lighter than the diesel. The diesel has more torque and is better in wet situations.
If it's for rocks, gravel and dirt/damp mud I'd go with the 1.6.
If it's for mud and wading, I'd go for the diesel.
Also, the bigger your wheels are, the more I'd lean towards the diesel, again because of torque. If you're leaving it with those that are on (Those alloys look really good by the way) I'd got for the 1.6.
Re: advice please ?
Posted: Wed Oct 03, 2012 9:49 pm
by dan_2k_uk
i cant see a need for anything but the 1.6 petrol.... but I'm biased!
Re: advice please ?
Posted: Wed Oct 03, 2012 10:05 pm
by Jay18
i like the idea of the 1.9 td conversion but to be honest the 1.6 vit engine conversion is the easiest..
and do you have the alloys for the red vit still? if so is there a spare? haha been after a spare alloy wheel for my sj...
Re: advice please ?
Posted: Thu Oct 04, 2012 8:50 am
by ROBBIE
Ive looked into doing a 1.9 td conversion and couple things went against it imo
You can get an adaptor plate but they were to much££ for me or vitara gearbox, you can change the bell house for one that mates up to the 1.9 again too much££
Too much work involved, reroute exhaust,engine mounts move rad, rewire loads and chop redo trans tunnel or body lift.
Its far too heavy
1.6 so much easier cheaper. Move drivers side engine mount and a bit of drilling of the block to match gearbox and maybe a bit of grinding to fit the starter simples
Re: advice please ?
Posted: Thu Oct 04, 2012 6:12 pm
by ali
looks like most people so far are going for the 1.6 option . thats kinda what i was thinking as well ! wont be doing much wading but if its there im game to give it a go lol
i do have an alloy wheel i actually have 5 with my spare tyres on them lol
and the alloys on the sj are staying i bought them for her as they were a set of 5 i must admit myself they do suit it .
could always put the diesel in the chassi of the tin top and go play lol now theres an idea ???
Re: advice please ?
Posted: Thu Oct 04, 2012 9:29 pm
by ScottieJ
1.6 all the way
easy to do and no extra weight
Re: advice please ?
Posted: Thu Oct 04, 2012 11:21 pm
by Edweird
ScottieJ wrote:1.6 all the way
easy to do and no extra weight
Less weight. The G16 is an alloy block. The F10 is steel.
Re: advice please ?
Posted: Fri Oct 05, 2012 10:58 am
by ScottieJ
Edweird wrote:ScottieJ wrote:1.6 all the way
easy to do and no extra weight
Less weight. The G16 is an alloy block. The F10 is steel.
But the F10 is a lot smaller, and the steel internals of the G16 are bigger. I can lift both and there really isn't much in it, would be interesting to get an f10 lump on the scales though to see.
Re: advice please ?
Posted: Fri Oct 05, 2012 5:02 pm
by Edweird
ScottieJ wrote:Edweird wrote:ScottieJ wrote:1.6 all the way
easy to do and no extra weight
Less weight. The G16 is an alloy block. The F10 is steel.
But the F10 is a lot smaller, and the steel internals of the G16 are bigger. I can lift both and there really isn't much in it, would be interesting to get an f10 lump on the scales though to see.
I've never seen the two side by side, but the F10 is a pretty small engine with very few ancillaries so you're probably right.
It would be interesting to see the two side by side and weighed.