Page 1 of 3

MOT Failure would be an understatement

Posted: Sun Apr 28, 2019 12:16 pm
by MrShuffle
So I got my Sj410 tested over the weekend. I knew that there was a problem with the axle (as in it wasn't really attached to much) and the tyres weren't the best. I'd planned on getting both of these repaired and I've got a set of u bolts and leaf spring perches to tighten everything back up...

But went to get the post mortem and was handed a rather large list shall we say. Quite a few things it failed on are what I'd planned to replace as I said above and I knew it'd need a bit of welding so I wasn't expecting a pass I'm not that deluded but the bearings and then emissions problem weren't planned for.

I'm not afraid to spend some money on it as I want to preserve it and keep it on the road but my question is: is it really worth spending a grand and a bit more when I paid £1750 for the car a few months ago and I've got a long list to work through to get it back up and running?

Any ideas or feedback would be greatly appreciated! Even if it is just to poke fun at my large list where it might have been easier to write what isn't an issue.

Re: MOT Failure would be an understatement

Posted: Sun Apr 28, 2019 1:01 pm
by Jordi
Not that bad really.

Knackered tyres. Some rot to sort and some general wear and tear maintenance. Shackle pins, bearings, brakes.

I’d just crack on work through the list.

Re: MOT Failure would be an understatement

Posted: Sun Apr 28, 2019 1:23 pm
by Anton
My gray one was way worse than that. I knew it would fail when I took it, but that just gave me a list of things to fix.

That shouldn't cost a grand to fix unless you're going to get the work done somewhere expensive - if you sort the mechanical bits yourself you could have all that stuff sorted for a couple of hundred in parts, if that.

As for the rust - pics would help us to help you there. I have a little bodywork to do on my red one, I've been wondering if I could braze in new metal rather than weld...

Just thinking out loud there, not making a suggestion.

viewtopic.php?f=22&t=7184&start=153

Re: MOT Failure would be an understatement

Posted: Sun Apr 28, 2019 4:58 pm
by ScottieJ
Looks all pretty simple to me, the rear wheel bearing is pretty easy to change and that will probably fix the brake imbalance as well.

Re: MOT Failure would be an understatement

Posted: Mon Apr 29, 2019 7:44 pm
by MrShuffle
Quick update - I've been told that I need a new axle because the old one is leaking and it's not holding fluid? This is where I'm out of my depth if I'm honest. I've currently left the car with my dad as I'm at work all day so I don't have the time to take it anywhere.

Found an axle casing - is this what I need or does it need a full axle? Or can it be fixed?

Re: MOT Failure would be an understatement

Posted: Mon Apr 29, 2019 10:15 pm
by Anton
Whoever told you that, please don't ask for their advice on Suzuki's again.

You don't throw away an axle that starts leaking, you change the seals. Throwing away an axle because one of the seals went bad is like scrapping a brand new car just because it ran out of petrol. Doesn't make sense.

Find out which seal is gone, and replace it. Simples.

https://www.jimnybits.com/sj-samurai/se ... parts.html

Call them and make sure the bits you need are in stock, and that you're ordering the right thing (there are differences between 410 axles and 413 axles and Samurai axles, although I *think* that they all use the same seals/bearings etc).

Re: MOT Failure would be an understatement

Posted: Tue Apr 30, 2019 7:04 am
by Jordi
Is it the seals?

Or has the axle rotted through? The usual place is the diff housing?

If it has rotted through you can just change the axle casing and swap every thing into it.

Just make sure the new case is the correct width. Later Samurai models has a wider axle compared to the older SJ413 and SJ410 models.

Re: MOT Failure would be an understatement

Posted: Tue Apr 30, 2019 7:45 pm
by andyrew
As jordi says, the axles can go porrus on the diff "pumpkin" mine went here and it weeped out diff oil.

Stick up some photos of the problem areas and some people should be able to suggest some fixes.

Re: MOT Failure would be an understatement

Posted: Wed May 01, 2019 1:11 pm
by Anton
Jordi wrote:
Tue Apr 30, 2019 7:04 am
Is it the seals?

Or has the axle rotted through? The usual place is the diff housing?

If it has rotted through you can just change the axle casing and swap every thing into it.

Just make sure the new case is the correct width. Later Samurai models has a wider axle compared to the older SJ413 and SJ410 models.
andyrew wrote:
Tue Apr 30, 2019 7:45 pm
As jordi says, the axles can go porrus on the diff "pumpkin" mine went here and it weeped out diff oil.

Stick up some photos of the problem areas and some people should be able to suggest some fixes.
I didn't think of that! I suppose if the case has rusted through, the new axle advice might be good advice after all.

I think we need more info on where/how the axle is leaking.

Re: MOT Failure would be an understatement

Posted: Sun May 05, 2019 3:10 pm
by Ju
Never good to see a list that big but it is all work that can be carried out by an amateur with a bit of time and willing